Most weeks I ride the unpaved roads between Unison, Bloomfield and the Fauquier line, and most weeks I meet more horses than cars. That ratio is the reason these roads matter. Pave them and it flips within a year.

I started Cycling Unbound in 2022 around one idea: the historic gravel roads of western Loudoun and Fauquier are worth riding, documenting and keeping. We run open rides every week, map the routes and publish them free, and write down what we learn about the villages the roads connect.

The case for pavement is easy to state. Gravel makes dust in August and mud in March. It needs grading. A paved road is cheaper to maintain per car that uses it.

That last clause carries the whole argument, and it is the part I disagree with. A gravel road is slow on purpose. Drivers hold 25 mph because the surface asks them to, and at that speed a rider, a walker, a horse trailer and a tractor can share nine feet of road without anyone being in danger. Pave the same road and it becomes a shortcut. Traffic finds it, speeds double, and the people who used it on foot, on a bike or in the saddle stop using it. The road gets cheaper per car because it now carries cars and nothing else.

There is also the simpler point that these roads are old, and the landscape was built around them. The stone walls, the bank barns and the stream fords sit where they do because the road was already there. Straighten and widen the road to modern standards and you take the walls and the tree line with it. What is left is a faster route through a place that no longer looks like itself.

Keeping them unpaved is a choice with costs, and the people who live on them carry those costs. So the least a rider can do is behave like a guest. Slow down for horses and say something before you pass, because a silent bike behind a horse is a hazard. Pull over for the farm truck. Ride single file when a car is waiting. Our rides teach this before they teach anything about fitness.

I would rather have a road that asks something of everyone on it than one that serves only the fastest vehicle. If you want to see what I mean, the route library at cyclingunbound.org is open, and so are the rides.